Shiny Penny Learns · Online

The Third
Coordinate

A course in musicianship and expression, for players and composers who already have technique and want to find out what they actually sound like.

Rhythm · time Pitch · space Expression

Rhythm and pitch are the two axes every musician is taught. Expression is treated as a finish applied to them. It isn't. It's a third axis, free to move on its own.

This outline is a template

What follows is a plan, not a schedule. No student receives these hours in the printed proportion.

Every course is built for the individual student. Before the first lesson we correspond, and a curriculum is drafted for you specifically — drawing on this template, reordered and reweighted around what you already have and what you're after. In the first hour we go through that curriculum together, openly. You question it. Every question gets an answer. When it's agreed, two copies are signed and each of us keeps one.

Lesson numbers below are positions in a sequence, not dates on a calendar. Where a student isn't ready to move on, the arc is extended rather than the next one begun.

Groups and cohorts are taught too, and the adaptation is written deliberately rather than improvised — a cohort of six trombonists, a cohort of six unrelated instruments, and a standing quartet are three different rooms.

What the hours are for

To find out what a musician actually sounds like — not what they might sound like after enough practice, but what is already there underneath the technique they kept and the technique they let go.

Your inner ear already hears the music you're capable of, with complete clarity. The trouble is never that the vision is absent. It's the distance between a brain that already knows and a body that hasn't caught up — and that distance has a feeling attached to it, usually misdiagnosed as nerves or as inadequacy. It's neither. It's information about where the work remains.

Suppose Friday night was perfect. What, then, is Saturday for?

Perfection as an aim fails, and not because it's out of reach — because it's a dead end, with nowhere to go from it. The third coordinate is what makes Saturday a different night. The rhythm and the pitches can be identical to Friday's and the music can still be new.

Two formats

Both are taught online, one hour at a time, by video link. Both carry the same architecture and teach all three coordinates. The short course loses dwell time, not content.

24 The full course

Three arcs of eight lessons, each closing with an evaluation. Cumulative: the second arc assumes the first, and the third isn't attempted before the second is in place.

16 The short course

Two arcs of eight. Four lessons are never compressed, because the course doesn't function without them at full length. Everything else gives ground first.

The full course, lesson by lesson

Arc I — Ground

Center of gravity, and the horizontal coordinate

  1. Intake and the Standing QuestionWhere does your sound start?
  2. Finding CenterThe center of gravity, located and loaded.
  3. Breath as DisplacementBreath moves from center. It is not taken from above.
  4. The Instrument Meets the CenterComfort is a technical criterion, not a courtesy.
  5. The Horizontal Coordinate — Pulse Before MeterBeat lives in the body before it lives on the page.
  6. Rhythm as WeightDuration is motion between weights, not arithmetic.
  7. The Comfortable PositionEvery place the body braces is named and remapped.
  8. Evaluation — The GroundEight weeks measured against where we began.

Arc II — Listen

The twenty-two areas, aesthetic cognition, and the vertical coordinate

  1. The Inner Ear Already KnowsAudiation. Hearing precedes sounding.
  2. The Twenty-Two AreasWhat actually processes music, and which parts are underused.
  3. Aesthetic CognitionThe intellectual, the physical, and the emotional fused into one act.
  4. Predictive BeautyExpectation, delay, and fulfillment.
  5. The Vertical Coordinate — Pitch as PlaceIntonation is location, not correction.
  6. Harmony as DepthHearing the harmony under your own line, alone.
  7. Melody as the Line ThroughThe path drawn through the vertical field.
  8. Evaluation — The FieldSixteen weeks. The horizontal and the vertical assessed.

Arc III — Speak

The third coordinate, the voice, and presence

  1. The Third Coordinate — Expression at Right AnglesExpression is an axis, not a garnish.
  2. The Feedback LoopPlay. Hear. Evaluate. Change. Play.
  3. The Courage ExercisePlay whatever comes. Chaos is permitted and required.
  4. Refining the ChaosWhat recurs is the voice.
  5. A Sense of OneselfNot the constructed self. The one that accrues.
  6. PresenceHolding the center under observation.
  7. Charisma and JoyTelling the audience it is all right to know what they know.
  8. Evaluation — The VoiceTwenty-four weeks. What continues without a teacher.

Who it's for

Advancing players and composers, on any instrument or none. Wind players, string players, singers, pianists, and writers all take the same course — the breathing work isn't a wind player's specialty, and composers are held to the movement work as strictly as performers, and usually need it more.

What you'll be asked to do

Keep a practice log. Record yourself, mostly for your own use. Move a passage before you play it. Sit three evaluations, each preceded by a questionnaire. Some of what you record is private by definition and is never submitted — the courage work in particular is yours alone unless you choose otherwise.

What you leave with

A written statement of what you sound like, a Continuation Plan drafted in the final hour, and the evaluation record kept in your own copy. The last half hour is given entirely to what continues after the course ends: which practices persist, which were scaffolding, and what you now do alone.

Asking for what you want

Read the outline with one question in hand — where does your sound start — and then write. Say what you play, what you're working on, and what you'd want twenty-four hours to do. The curriculum gets drafted from there.

Write to Scott